The aftershocks of Gen Con 2018 just keep coming. It was an amazing con, and one of the highlights was the big DCC Team Tournament.
The 2018 Gen Con DCC Team Tournament brought together Judges and players alike as they competed in our title event, Riders on the Phlogiston. This year 98 players competing on 18 different teams took on the deadly challenge, more than doubling the size of the last year’s tournament. Over the course of four brutal days and three hard-fought rounds, many PCs fell and a record number of teams were wiped out in TPKs. Eventually two champions emerged: the first place Hammertoes and the runner-up Lords of Sarcasm. You can read Harley’s recap of the tournament here.
We now present the official tournament stats, including all the Judges, rooms and authors that contributed to this year’s amazing event. And we’re proud to introduce the Count Dante Tournament Rating System! This is a new rating scale for the deadliest tournament modules based on actual play results, described below.
Now, let’s get right to the results!
Round 1 Results
Place | Team | Round Score | Players | Judge |
1 | Hammertoes | 3235 | Rob Swanson, Martin Bruinicki, Jack Bruinicki, Will Bruinicki, Hayden Hodge, Lance Hodge | Tim Deschene |
2 | The Goat Men | 1484 | Chris Page, Mike Mullins, Gord Lyle, Nick Cassidy, Craig Lewin, Nick Robinette | Eric Daum |
3 | Lords of Sarcasm, ESWM | 951 | David York, Fred Daily, Nate Garth, Jason Riddell, Ken Burnette, Patrick Biddix | Aaron Koelman |
4 | Vice Squad | 892 | Zach Starkey, Rob Collins, John Neireiter, Dani Howe-Danhauer, Joshua Swanson, Andrew Danhauer | Aaron Koelman |
5 | The Herculoids | 362 | Kevin Omans, Tar Druggan, Chris Hartigan, Ken Winland, Mark Goddard, Gary Ruiz | Marc Bruner |
6 | 50′ of Misanthropes | 125* | Sarah Van Horn, Jeff Van Horn, Haley Skach, Alan Fishman, Jim Skach | Tim Deschene |
7 | The Clique | -50* | Chris Dodd, Jane Ritt, Will Wagner, Evan Ritt, Zeke Dodd, Tobias Loc | Rick Hull |
8 | Dynamic Duo | -99 | Tim Loughrist, Troy Tucker | Aaron Koelman |
9 | Crypt-Kicker Six | -300* | Mike Markey, Sean Smith, Silas Moore, Joe Moore, Michael Brewington, Andrew Kluessendorf | Terry Olson |
10 (Tie) | The Banishers | -550* | Skylar Hsu, Ian Johnson, Ed Hsu, David Schmidlin, Jeremiah Rose, Ian Welsh | Jeff Goad |
10 (Tie) | Awesome Mongooses | -550* | Aaron Winemiller, Chris Lone, Pete Doroshenko, Spencer Miller, Jeremy Earl, Erik Stuart | Jeff Goad |
10 (Tie) | Exiles of Oz | -550* | Warner Peng, Trevor Stamper, Jeremy Haupt, John Olszewski, Brian Gilkison, Barry Peng | Terry Olson |
13 | Three Caster Disaster | -859* | Nick McKinnon, Paul Romer, Ross Grinvalds, Matt Free, Jason Mulvey, Jordan McCarrel | Michael Bolam |
14 | The Scrappy Underdogs | -1100* | Chris Bonno, Dylan Holland, Mike Dischida, Colin Murphree, Gary Soldati, Melissa Mauchmor | Jeff Goad |
15 | Team Chaos | -2100* | John Senz, Michael Ross, Tom Ziegler, Terry Walsh, Peter Sotos | Michael Bolam |
16 | Death is for Loserz | -2150* | Charlie Goren, George Hope, Richard Mundy, Kent Duncan, Emily Mundy, Lance DeClue | Terry Olson |
17 | Evie & the Destroyers | -2800* | Keith Haddad, Evie Walls, Ray Stephens, Josh Salter | Tim Deschene |
18 | Smegmapolites!! | -3950* | Ryan Bassler, Andrew Smitley, Steve Seminerio, Cory Welch, Jim Smitley | Eric Daum |
* Games that ended in a TPK
Round 2 Results
Place | Team | Round Score | Players | Judge |
1 | Lords of Sarcasm, ESWM | 6159 | David York, Fred Daily, Nate Garth, Jason Riddell, Ken Burnette, Patrick Biddix | Tim Deschene |
2 | Hammertoes | 5245 | Rob Swanson, Martin Bruinicki, Jack Bruinicki, Will Bruinicki, Hayden Hodge, Lance Hodge | Marc Bruner |
3 | The Goat Men | 3145 | Chris Page, Mike Mullins, Gord Lyle, Nick Cassidy, Craig Lewin, Nick Robinette | Harley Stroh |
4 | Vice Squad | 2272 | Zach Starkey, Rob Collins, John Neireiter, Dani Howe-Danhauer, Joshua Swanson, Andrew Danhauer | Michael Bolam |
Round 3 Results
Place | Team | Round Score | Players | Judge |
1** | Hammertoes | -1200* | Rob Swanson, Martin Bruinicki, Jack Bruinicki, Will Bruinicki, Hayden Hodge, Lance Hodge | Harley Stroh |
2 | Lords of Sarcasm, ESWM | -1200* | David York, Fred Daily, Nate Garth, Jason Riddell, Ken Burnette, Patrick Biddix | Marc Bruner |
* Games that ended in a TPK
**Tie breaker determined by a d20 dice-off during the awards ceremony at the Goodman Games booth, where the Lords of Sarcasm rolled a ‘7’ and the Hammertoes rolled an ‘8’ to carry the victory!
TPKs by Round and Judge
Round | TPKs | Teams | TPK % | Top TPK Judges |
1 | 12 | 18 | 67% | Tie – Terry Olson and Jeff Goad (3) |
2 | 0 | 4 | 0% | N/A |
3 | 2 | 2 | 100% | Tie – Harley Stroh and Marc Bruner (1) |
Deadliest Rooms by Round
Round | Room | Author | % of Total PC Fatalities in Round |
1 | Area 1-4 – Engine Control Room | Steve Bean | 40% |
2 | Area 2-3 – The High Spoils | Harley Stroh | 23% |
3 | Area 3-2 – Fear is the Mind Killer | Marc Bruner | 33% |
Deadliest Judges
Judge | Ratio of Fatalities to Total Number of Players | Total PC Fatalities | Total Players |
Terry Olson | 2.5:1 | 42 | 17 |
Jeff Goad | 2.4:1 | 44 | 18 |
Rick Hull | 2.3:1 | 14 | 6 |
Michael Bolam | 1.6:1 | 28 | 17 |
Marc Bruner | 1.6:1 | 29 | 18 |
Tim Deschene | 1.6:1 | 33 | 21 |
Harley Stroh | 1.3:1 | 16 | 12 |
Eric Daum | 1.3:1 | 14 | 11 |
Aaron Koelman | 0.8:1 | 11 | 14 |
Jonathan Perkel | Mathematically undefined! | 0 | 0 |
Deadliest Tournament Modules
Introducing the Count Dante Tournament Rating System! Because tournament modules are played at Gen Con over a large sample of tables and judges, we are able to quantify their danger level. Based on this quantification we have a new rating system to use as a guide when selecting your next adventure to run. Here are the ratings for this year and last year’s tournament adventures, Riders of the Phlogiston and The Black Heart of Thakulon the Undying. Future tournament modules will also use this rating system once they are put through their paces at Gen Con or other large gaming events!
Adventure | Count Dante Dungeon Rating* | Ratio of Killed PCs | Total PCs Killed | Total Players |
Riders of the Phlogiston – Gen Con 2018 | IV | 0.62:1 | 83 | 134 |
The Black Heart of Thakulon the Undying – Gen Con 2017 | II | 0.35:1 | 23 | 65 |
*Based on the ratio of killed PCs (eliminated) to players for every PC that entered the dungeon across all rounds:
Type I – 0.0 to 0.2:1
Type II – 0.2 to 0.4:1
Type III – 0.4 to 0.6:1
Type IV – 0.6 to 0.8:1
Type V – 0.8 to 0.99:1
Type VI – 1:1, or 100% lethal!
Most Popular Pre-gens
1. Lawful Wizard (13 out of 18 teams selected)
2. (Tie) Lawful Cleric (12 out of 18 teams selected)
2. (Tie) Lawful Dwarf (12 out of 18 teams selected)
4. (Tie) Lawful Warrior (10 out of 18 teams selected)
4. (Tie) Neutral Halfling (10 out of 18 teams selected)
6. Chaotic Cleric (9 out of 18 teams selected)
7. Chaotic Warrior (8 out of 18 teams selected)
8. (Tie) Lawful Thief (7 out of 18 teams selected)
8. (Tie) Chaotic Thief (7 out of 18 teams selected)
10. (Tie) Chaotic Wizard (5 out of 18 teams selected)
10. (Tie) Chaotic Elf (5 out of 18 teams selected)
Notable Team Compositions
- Holy rollers: Teams with two clerics – 3
- Let the warrior open it: Teams without a thief – 4
- Power magic-users: Teams with four or more spellcasters – 2
- Let the gods decide: Total number of lawful vs chaotic characters – 54 vs 34
Special Awards
- First Blood, Part 2: Judge Michael was out for revenge from his showing last year and managed to TPK Team Chaos in the first hour and a fifteen minutes of the tournament!
- Triple Crown Favorite: For the second year, Judge Terry was one of the most lethal elements of the tournament, last year as a writer, this year as a judge.
- Almost Broke the Designer’s Hearts: In the very first roll of round 1 at Judge Jeff’s table, a young player rolled a natural 20 on her cleric’s spell check, only to fall to the dice minutes later, bringing her participation in the tournament to an end and dooming her team. However, the tournament staff watched in awe as Judge Jeff kept the whole table engaged even as the rest of the team fell one by one until only a single PC remained, whose epic story unfolded to the cheers of his party.
- The Backup Master: Judge Rick not only helped behind the scenes with all the coordination efforts for the tournament, but had to be prepared to run in any of the judge’s slots in case there was an issue. His masterful preparation payed off when he was called to serve in the second day of round 1, taking his table through almost four hours of play to an eventual TPK!
- Atlas of the Phlogiston: Judge Tim shouldered an amazing four teams and 21 players across two rounds of the tournament, meaning that 1 out of every 6 PCs went through his tables.
- The Student is Now the Master: After helping behind the scenes last year, Judge Eric made his debut as both a writer and a judge, and took the crown of earliest team TPK in round one!
- All Shall Pass, Sort-of: Judge Aaron’s three teams had the least amount of deaths for any tournament judge, but in a very deadly year he still managed to take out 11 characters that came through his table!
- Robbed of Glory: Judge Jonathan prepped just as hard as any other judge, but fell to the fates when Gen Con no-shows caused a consolidation of his table with another judge’s. However, he ultimately earned a symbiotic victory when the newly aggregated team fell less than two hours later.
- Divine Salesman: Judge Marc had not one, but two teams use divine aid for the first time in tournament history, with one of the clerics rolling a natural “30” on his d30 spell check granted by the gods.
- Deadliest Portal: In the first round, Judge Harley’s door-artifacts slew more players than the actual monsters as the PCs struggled to pass through them against a ticking clock. A dozen PCs were crushed, maimed, and trapped over the course of a few rounds, making teams that could not find an easy way through spend valuable time and resources to overcome the devious obstacles.
Complete Stats by Room
Round 1
Room | Author | % of Total PC Fatalities in Round |
Player Start – The Summoning Circle | Harley Stroh | 13% |
1-1 – The Activated Phlogiston | Harley Stroh | 9% |
1-2 – The Cell of the Speaker | Julian Bernick | 18% |
1-3 – Magnetic Freezer | Terry Olson | 6% |
1-4 – Engine Control Bay | Steve Bean | 40% |
1-5 – Frigid Hive of Mutillidae Nanocordyceps | Steve Bean | 9% |
1-6 – Lagomorph Labs | Steve Bean | 1% |
1-7 – Mutation Purification | Terry Olson | 0%* |
1-8 – Smart Metal Assembly and Repair | Terry Olson | 1% |
1-9 – The Creator / Escape Portal | Harley Stroh | 1% |
* Rooms that no teams reached during the tournament
Round 2
Room | Author | % of Total PC Fatalities in Round |
2-1 – The Bird, the Gas, and the Scroll Case | Terry Olson | 14% |
2-2 – The Low Spoils | Harley Stroh | 0% |
2-3 – He Who Draws the Axe from the Coal | Terry Olson | 14% |
2-4 – Trapped Corridor | Harley Stroh | 9% |
2-5 – A Sizable Hanging | Terry Olson | 14% |
2-6 – The High Spoils | Harley Stroh | 23% |
2-7 – Dying for Plate | Terry Olson | 0% |
2-8 – Music of the Spoils | Marc Bruner | 14% |
2-9 – Shadders! | Marc Bruner | 14% |
2-10 – A Gander at the Ganderbeast | Terry Olson | 0% |
2-11 – Escape from the Shudder Mines | Harley Stroh | 0%* |
* Rooms that no teams reached during the tournament
Round 3
Room | Author | % of Total PC Fatalities in Round |
3-1 – Death by Orm Swarm | Terry Olson | 22% |
3-2 – Fear is the Mind Killer | Marc Bruner | 33% |
3-3 – Dead Fall | Harley Stroh | 0% |
3-4 – Tomb of the Gribb-Kith Mummies | Terry Olson | 30% |
3-6 – Sepulcher of the Crystalline Masters | Terry Olson | 15% |
3-7 – The Emerald Prison | Marc Bruner | 0%* |
3-8 – The Way Home | Eric Daum | 0%* |
* Rooms that no teams reached during the tournament