Page 1 of 1

Which is a better Conversion to DCC, Pathfinder or S&W

Posted: Mon Nov 18, 2013 8:51 am
by soundmana
There is a product that I would like to buy called Hex Crawl Chronicles by Frog God games. My main concern is converting it over to DCC, the monster stats and traps lethality and such. I'm still a little new with DCC and am still learning where it's borrowing its mechanics from. It looks to me there is alot from D20 (refl, fort, and will) stats, and ascending AC. There doesn't seem to be as much high point bloat that Pathfinder has, looking at the monster HP and stats. In my view DCC seems closer to AD&D or OD&D in this respect.

Hex Crawl Chronicles comes in two different formats, one for Pathfinder, one for S&W Complete( which is close to OD&D w/supplements). I was wondering what everyone's view was on this as maybe then I can make a decision on which version to get to use in my DCC game. I would rather have less work converting over monsters mainly.

I have more experience DMing and playing OD&D/AD&D than Pathfinder if this has any relevance.

Re: Which is a better Conversion to DCC, Pathfinder or S&W

Posted: Tue Nov 19, 2013 7:26 am
by Skars
It sounds like your questions were largely answered in your own statement. :) Go with the S&W version as it is in a format you are already comfortable with and regardless of which you choose, they won't translate directly. The only reason I would consider the Pathfinder version might have been the DC levels for traps but honestly they are pretty easy to assume.

Re: Which is a better Conversion to DCC, Pathfinder or S&W

Posted: Tue Nov 19, 2013 8:02 am
by GnomeBoy
The Skars are right.

Re: Which is a better Conversion to DCC, Pathfinder or S&W

Posted: Tue Nov 19, 2013 8:27 am
by IronWolf
I would go with the S&W version. It will distill the relevant stats down to what is needed vs. having to filter through a Pathfinder stat block pulling out what you need and disregarding the rest.

Re: Which is a better Conversion to DCC, Pathfinder or S&W

Posted: Tue Nov 19, 2013 8:54 am
by ragboy
My experience with the Hex Crawl stuff is limited to the first one -- The stats/gamey stuff is well separated from the rest of the text, so it's super easy to find and convert. I'd second Swords and Wizardry. It was perfect for my group since we play both S&W and DCC.